Which negotiation tactics are most effective?

A procurement professional often faces the challenge of maximizing the value of a deal by securing the best possible terms in terms of price, quality, delivery times, and other factors.
There are several tactics that can be used, each with varying degrees of effectiveness depending on the context of the negotiation. Here are some of the main tactics:
a) BATNA (Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement) or MANA (Best Alternative for Negotiating an Agreement)
• What it is: The concept of MANA refers to the best available alternative if negotiations are not successful. Having a strong MANA gives you bargaining power, since you won’t be dependent on a single supplier.
• How to use: Purchasing professionals should always evaluate, identify, and strengthen their alternatives before beginning negotiations. If a supplier does not offer acceptable terms, the company can turn to others who present similar proposals. This reduces dependence and allows the company to push for better terms. In summary: always try to have a backup option (one that meets your needs just as well); otherwise, your supplier will hold the upper hand in the negotiation.
b) Anchoring
• What it is: Anchoring a negotiation means being the first to make an offer, thereby setting a benchmark for the negotiation. This benchmark can influence the rest of the conversation.
• How to use: When entering into a negotiation, the professional can suggest an initial price or condition (provided it is reasonable) that is advantageous to the company. This helps shape the supplier’s expectations around that figure and keeps subsequent concessions within a favorable range. Be careful not to overstate the value of the proposal (seeking an excessive advantage for your side), as the other party may feel offended and end any possibility of an agreement—and please, never bluff!
c) Gradual Concession Technique
• What it is: This tactic involves making small, incremental concessions rather than large, one-time adjustments. By doing so, the professional gives the impression that each concession is valuable and difficult to offer.
• How to use: For example, instead of immediately granting a request for a significant discount, the procurement professional can offer a smaller discount initially, while waiting for concessions from the supplier, such as better payment terms or delivery conditions. As a rule, this technique often ends in the famous “neither you nor me…” scenario, but it usually yields good results.
d) Joint Value Creation
• What it is: Instead of treating negotiation as a zero-sum game, where one side wins and the other loses, this approach seeks opportunities to create value for both parties. This can be done by identifying areas where the interests of both sides align.
• How to use it: The procurement professional can ask the supplier if there are ways to improve processes that benefit both parties, such as long-term fixed-price agreements, innovation partnerships, or larger purchase volumes in exchange for better terms. This approach helps build strong, lasting relationships. While it generally isn’t worthwhile for spot negotiations, it often yields excellent long-term results with regular suppliers by strengthening the relationship.
e) The Technique of "Silence" and Patience
• What it is: The strategic use of silence or pauses during negotiations can be effective in forcing the other side to reflect or even to offer better terms on their own.
• How to use it: After making a request or counteroffer, the negotiator can deliberately remain silent, allowing the supplier to react. The discomfort of the silence sometimes leads the other side to fill the gap with a more favorable proposal. This tactic is typically used in negotiations where the other side is very inflexible and/or resistant, but it tends to be effective if you know they really need to do business with you or if you have other good alternatives in case you can’t reach an agreement.
Combine tactics:
Typically, no single tactic is used in isolation; combining strategies based on the specific situation is usually much more effective. For example, a professional might start with a strong anchor, follow up with gradual concessions, and conclude by seeking a shared-value agreement.
Always try to assess the context of the negotiation: what are the market conditions, what is your company’s bargaining power (MANA), how much does the supplier need to close the deal with you, and what is the supplier’s profile (does the supplier play hardball, is the supplier inflexible, is the supplier transparent, etc.)?
